Scaling CX Without Losing the Customer Experience: A Conversation with 32 Degrees' Jennifer Villalba
Watch the Live Recording
Introduction
Jennifer Villalba, Director of Customer Experience at 32 Degrees, joins Lisa Painter to talk about what actually breaks when a CX org scales, and how she's kept her team consistent through chaotic Q4s, warehouse blackouts, and rapid AI adoption. Jennifer shares the rookie mistake that taught her not to make staffing decisions based on a single good day, why she cut NPS in favor of more actionable feedback, and how a simple internal Slack channel gave her agents the confidence to make VIP customer calls on their own. They also dig into where AI genuinely helps, like low-lift post-purchase questions, and where it should never replace a human, especially in emotional, high-stakes moments.
At the core, CXers really care about their people. And I think that's always just going to stay the same.
Jennifer Villalba
Director of CX, 32 Degrees
Key Takeaways
Don't staff based on one good day
After a strong stretch of Q4 metrics, Jennifer scaled back five agents in January. The next day, response times spiked as warehouse issues hit, teaching her to plan for the bigger picture instead of what's happening today.
Cut feedback channels that repeat themselves
Jennifer eliminated NPS because it surfaced the same complaints CSAT and reviews already captured, freeing her team to focus on more actionable feedback.
A high automation rate isn't good service
Jennifer pushes back on the idea that a bigger automation number means better CX; her team's more selective approach performs just as well, if not better.
Give agents guardrails, not gatekeepers
A VIP internal Slack channel lets agents make judgment calls for trusted, high-value customers without escalating first, and CSAT has stayed above 4.3 ever since.
Explain the why before rolling out new tools
When onboarding tools like Digital Genius, Jennifer uses SOPs, Loom videos, and an open Slack line to keep her team informed instead of confused.
Meet the Guest
Jennifer Villalba is Director of Customer Experience at 32 Degrees, where she leads a core team of 20 (scaling seasonally) through the brand's biggest volume swings, including Q4. She calls her team the frontline "firefighters" of the business, the first to spot what's breaking and the ones who have to think fast under pressure. Jennifer pairs AI and automation with human judgment, especially in emotional or high-stakes customer moments, and keeps her team informed as the tools around them change.
